
The Plains of Passage
Earth's Children, Book 4
Failed to add items
Add to basket failed.
Add to wishlist failed.
Remove from wishlist failed.
Adding to library failed
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
3 months free
Buy Now for £16.99
No valid payment method on file.
We are sorry. We are not allowed to sell this product with the selected payment method
-
Narrated by:
-
Rowena Cooper
-
By:
-
Jean M. Auel
About this listen
Ayla and Jondalar leave the safety of the lands of the Mammoth Hunters and embark on a seemingly impossible journey across an entire continent. Their goal is the Cro-Magnon settlement in what is now southern France where Jondalar lived as a young man. Accompanied by the half-tame Wolf, the superb stallion, Racer, and the mare, Whinney, they brave both savage enemies and the elemental dangers of weather and terrain in their search for the place that will become Home.
Jean Auel's imaginative reconstruction of pre-historic life, rich in detail of language, culture, myth and ritual, has become a set text in schools and colleges around the world.
©1990 Jean M. Auel (P)1992 AudioGO Ltdfantastic book
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
Good, but not her best.
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
the saga of the Iceage
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
Throughout the journey, Ayla has a recurring dream about Creb leading her to a cave with a strange rock formation (which as it turns out, is Jondalar's home). This is repeated in almost every chapter. I get that the spirit of Creb is guiding her, which is really sweet and saves their lives on occasion, but it is repeated so often that it gets quite tiresome (oh no, not that bloody dream AGAIN ) and rather over-eggs the pudding.
The dream isn't the only thing oft-repeated. Surely nobody begins reading book 4 in a series and needs the entire contents of the 3 preceding books rehashed? This book was made far longer that need be by all the endless repetition of previous events. How many times do we need to hear again about Ayla's childhood events, Creb's favourite ptarmigan recipe ("the fat birds with the feathered feet") And Ayla's instinctive posture-directed control of her horse and speech abnormality which is "not unattractive but unusual" ?
Auel also doesn't lose an opportunity to lecture us, the modern reader, on the dangers of ignoring/plundering/polluting the Great Earth Mother at our peril!
Rowena, the narrator, in her very precise, plummy Queen's English, has expressive reading but sticks to several main voice tones : the lecturing tone she adopts when describing the landscape and natural history, the very repetitive slightly reproving, cautionary schoolma'am tone, the mildly encouraging tone used for describing events, the excited shocked/slightly disapproving tone for when a character shows wonder, and the slightly raised, mildly upset tone that does duty for every other emotional disturbance, from fury to despair. I have had to repeatedly imagine to myself what a character crying hysterically or furiously angry would ACTUALLY sound like.
I was also driven to distraction by the ENDLESS recounting of the exact, detailed habits and appearance of every single animal, every stripe on every horse's leg, every blade of grass and bend in the river, the exact appearance and use of every type of plant, every habitat detail, every migration pattern and ecological niche of every species, every mammoth penis... even every time the 2 travellers piss on the ground! - which, though giving background knowledge, tended to interrupt the flow of the story unecessarily with repetitive and far too lengthy natural history lectures (showing off Auel's extensive research so as not to waste it) that had me fast forwarding 10 minutes at a time.
Even when Ayla falls down a crevasse in the ice and is left precariously clinging to a ledge, we have to immediately endure a long geology lecture about the process of ice cave and moraine formation. OK, I get it! You did shedloads of research, great! That's what makes the story realistic and believable. But I don't need every last detail of it regurgitated every few minutes. I just want to enjoy the bloody STORY!!
This book comes across rather as if the "story" is just a veneer to give an excuse to spout on about Ice Age history.
Repetitive!!
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
enjoyed the whole book
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
excellent as always in this series
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
good stuff
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
Repetitive
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
Descriptive writing of the journey on the glacier
Narrator gets 5 stars she is brilliant
The plains of passage
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
Enthralling and exciting
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.