The Facts

Excellent book,fact filled and fair.Kathleen Stock is absolutely not transphobic,on the contrary she wants to understand the phenomenon.I agree with the fact that transwomen are not women but biologically 100% male and always will be so if you don’t agree with that you might not like this book which is researched very well and completely destroys some transactivists ideas which are pretty crazy.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Thoughtful

Thoughtful, well reasoned and carefully evidenced analysis. Compassionate and persuasive. Important reading for anyone concerned about the erosion of women's rights and lesbian/gay rights.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great material, and not just for girls.

A comprehensive and detailed review of this present-day war zone, which clearly explains the issues and controversies. I really enjoyed and thoroughly recommend this book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Logical and balanced examination of facts

At last someone saying compassionately but clearly what the vast majority of women think . Views I felt were somehow shameful to hold are examined carefully and validated .

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A much needed counterbalance

Articulates a view counter to the current affirmation at all cost trend in gender theory. Everyone making decisions around trans rights should read this, especially if it’s outside your echo chamber.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A balanced and straightforward overview

Stock delivered an essential piece of work for the current “trans debate”. Easy to follow and founded in reason, with compassion for both sides of the argument and advice on moving toward progress.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

An excellent book

A really enjoyable read, very accessable for everyone, clearly, precisely and cogently argued. Great to read a book by someone who is clearly taking a strong stance on the importance of biological sex but who clearly values knowledge kindness and corurtesyrdt f - both in terms of the solutions she proposes and in terms of the tone of her writing. One of the best books to read if you want you understand the way the dramatic shifts in our understanding of what gender is have come about/ been contrived. I was glad to listen to something by someone clearly trying to make a productive contribution and present evidence and arguments rather than just to keep making assertions.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

9 people found this helpful

Profound analysis of Trans Ideology and its consequences.

This is a rigorous and lucid examination of Trans Ideology. Stock forensically and carefully examines the evolution of the concept of ‘Gender Identity’ and associated ideas and demolishes what passes for academic work in this field, such as the belief that sex is socially constructed. This is as thorough and detailed a philosophical examination as you would expect from a philosopher, and shames the rest of the academic world in its acceptance of the half-baked theories which make up Trans ideology. But Stock is no transphobe. She is a vigorous defender of the human rights of trans people and argues compassionately for a real understanding of what underlies the desire to ‘change sex’ in and how society should respond in a humane and understanding way. She observes that trans ideology has morphed into a campaign to obliterate sex differences to the detriment of society and particularly to women and girls. Girls are now the majority of people identifying with another sex (or none) and social contagion mixed up with other issues, such as autism, anxiety about puberty, objectification of women, depression, and self-harming is being treated as simply a case of gender identity leading to puberty blockers and irreversible surgery. Some detransitioners now profoundly regret what they have done to their bodies. For producing this outstanding academic work, Stock has been vilified. If you want an example of how to write a readable yet highly academic work, this is perfect.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Clear thinking, evidence-based and compassionate

Kathleen Stock does a great job of reviewing, diagnosing and suggesting ways forward in the heated debate around gender identity. I found it extremely helpful and thought-provoking. I'd be very interested to read the response of proponents of gender identity theory to her arguments.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Amazing and mind blowing

A book that all women with the slightest concern for their womanhood should read. It’s heavy going in some parts but so well read.
Finished it feeling like the world is going made and women are being slowly erased!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful