Welcome to The Fan Debate, brought to you by Sky Bet! In this episode, Jamie Carragher and Paul Scholes reflect on their journeys into punditry.

Scholes discusses his unexpected entry into the industry, while Carragher explains why he prefers the high-pressure environment of co-commentary over studio analysis. The duo also talks about the criticisms they've faced along the way, and reveal their on-air regrets!

The pair also touch on the impact of social media and how they deal with online backlash. Plus, find out why Jamie never went into coaching - despite giving it a try towards the end of his playing career.

This show is sponsored by Trainline. With Trainline, you won't score cheaper same-day tickets anywhere else, or we'll refund the difference! Book now at https://www.thetrainline.com

If you're enjoying The Overlap Fan Debate, please hit subscribe to never miss an episode, and consider leaving us a five-star review to help others discover the show. Thank you for listening!

00:00 Promo

00:56 Transition From Player to Pundit

05:50 Is there a bias when Co-Commentating your team?

10:12 Player Reactions and Backlash

17:30 Do Jamie and Paul Have Any Regrets?

22:26 Advice for Retiring Players

27:47 How Have Things Changed Since Jamie and Paul Played?

29:28 Challenges for Female Commentators

30:59 Handling Criticism in Punditry

32:20 Insight into Dressing Room Reactions

35:00 The Importance of Detailed Analysis

38:31 Preparation for Monday Night Football

41:42 Why Jamie Didn't Pursue Coaching

43:23 Dealing with Media Misrepresentation

50:43 Balancing Tough Interviews

52:09 Favourite Snacks During Punditry

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

In this episode of The Fan Debate brought to you by Sky Bet, Jamie Carragher and Paul Scholes are joined by football finance expert Kieran Maguire. We get an update on the ongoing case surrounding Manchester City. If the club is found guilty, what could the future of the Premier League look like? The team debates what a fair punishment would be and how it could reshape the league’s landscape.

The conversation then shifts to Liverpool, as lifelong fan Gareth shares his perspective on Trent Alexander-Arnold’s potential move to Real Madrid. Are Liverpool fans being unfair in their criticism of the transfer?

Manchester United’s midfield also comes under the spotlight, with questions raised about how the club can get the best out of Kobbie Mainoo following his dip in form under Rúben Amorim. What has changed in his performances, and can he rediscover his best form in Amorim's system?

The team also discusses Aston Villa’s balancing act between the Champions League and FA Cup, Arsenal’s ongoing striker dilemma, and who Mikel Arteta should target in the summer transfer window.

This show is sponsored by Trainline. With Trainline, you won't score cheaper same-day tickets anywhere else, or we'll refund the difference! Book now at https://www.thetrainline.com

If you're enjoying The Overlap Fan Debate, please hit subscribe to never miss an episode, and consider leaving us a five-star review to help others discover the show. Thank you for listening!

00:00 - Intro

02:48 - Manchester City

16:58 - The Winning Track

21:20 - City Continued

25:27 - Liverpool

26:34 - Trent Alexander-Arnold

31:32 - Everton

35:05 - Arsenal

40:35 - Manchester United

47:10 - Brighton

49:20 - Ipswich Town

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

In this episode of the Fan Debate brought to you by Sky Bet, Jamie Carragher and Paul Scholes are joined by former Premier League (and current Gladiators!) referee Mark Clattenburg.

The show kicks off with Mark opening up about his role as Referee Consultant at Nottingham Forest, including the backlash that came with that.

We'll hear about player conflicts - including Craig Bellamy and Adam Lallana - as well as his heated relationship with with Jurgen Klopp, plus Jose Mourinho’s charm.

Mark then delves into his controversial refereeing decisions, the impact of VAR and the difficulty of dealing with social media backlash. Plus, we get the reason behind Clattenburg’s tattoos, the highs and lows of his career and officiating major finals.

If you're enjoying The Overlap Fan Debate, please hit subscribe to never miss an episode, and consider leaving us a five-star review to help others discover the show. Thank you for listening!

00:00 – Intro

01:52 – Mark Clattenburg at Nottingham Forest

07:13 – Referees Declaring Their Football Team

15:06 – Mark Clattenburg’s Role as Referee Consultant at Nottingham Forest

19:00 – Mark Clattenburg’s Journey to Refereeing

22:18 – Mark Clattenburg’s Clash with Craig Bellamy + Adam Lallana

27:17 – The Impact of Social Media on Referees

31:50 – Manchester United’s Mind Games and Jose Mourinho’s Charm

33:11 – Clattenburg’s Clash with Jurgen Klopp

37:08 – Refereeing Bayern Munich v Barcelona in the Champions League

39:51 – Refereeing Mistakes in the Merseyside Derby

43:26 – Champions League Final: Real Madrid v Atletico Madrid

46:53 – Clattenburg’s Tattoos

49:50 – Clattenburg’s Thoughts on VAR

53:06 – Do Referees Have an Agenda Against Certain Clubs?

55:48 – The Best Referee in the Premier League Right Now + Chat on Added Time

01:06:10 – What Rule in Football Would Mark Clattenburg Change?

01:09:07 – Flav Takes on a Tottenham Hotspur Quiz

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.