Send us a text

Welcome to "Pick This Show" with hosts Scott, Mike, and Ryan. Off their global hit “Trackin’ Tracker,” this season finds the hosts kicking off a fresh new format. This year, they'll each nominate a new show and convince the other hosts why their pick should be the one they all watch. After discussions, they'll vote to determine which show to watch. They will continue watching and discussing the chosen show until at least two hosts decide to stop, prompting a new round of nominations. Listen in as Scott, Mike, and Ryan battle it out on which show should be picked (Physical - AppleTV, Doctor Odyssey - ABC, or All American - CW) and discuss what makes Rose Byrne unstoppable, how Charlie Conway and Pacey Witter will make a deadly combo at sea, and can All-American live up to the holy grail of teenage football dramas Friday Night Lights.

00:00 Introduction to Season Two Format

01:06 Scott's Show Nomination: Physical

08:55 Mike's Show Nomination: Doctor Odyssey

16:19 Ryan Murphy's Signature Style

16:38 Comparing '911' and 'Dr. Odyssey'

17:15 The Love Boat Meets Grey's Anatomy

17:26 Speculating on 'Dr. Odyssey's' Format

18:12 Popularity of '911'

19:22 Introducing 'All American'

20:05 Plot and Themes of 'All American'

23:26 Pros and Cons of 'All American'

29:31 Voting and Final Thoughts

Send us a text

Ryan, Mike, and Scott have made it through a full season of Tracker! The gang breaks down how you can't fool Colter Shaw, who's batting a 1,000. Colter finds a missing storm chaser and breaks down a criminal sex trader. The hosts examine how fucked up the Shaw family is, why all surfers have to be Australian, what elements can improve the show, and their love of the show's use of high-budget oldies rock songs. The gang also pitch their ideas for future storylines and says goodbye to the global phenomena that has become Trackin' Tracker.

00:00 Introduction and Episode Overview
01:32 Discussion on Episode's Simplicity
11:31 Family Dynamics and Season 2 Setup
23:54 Final Thoughts and Season Recap
24:32 Debating the Worst Episode
24:56 Favorite Episodes and Missed Opportunities
31:12 The Need for Better Side Characters
33:38 Suggestions for Season Two
44:31 Final Thoughts and Ratings
46:18 Looking Ahead to Season Two

Send us a text

In this episode of Trackin’ Tracker, Scott, Ryan, and Mike celebrate the long-awaited appearance of Russell Shaw, the enigmatic brother who supposedly killed the Shaw family patriarch. The gang tries to understand if it’s possible to overcome a complex 20 year absence in 10 minutes, which brother is better for Reenie, why the director cut out all of the action scenes, and if they could run a family business with their own sibling.

00:36 Character Analysis: Russell Shaw
02:59 Plot Breakdown: Colter and Russ Reunite
04:52 Action and Banter: The Brothers' Dynamic
06:04 Russell's Flirtations and Character Depth
06:50 Critique of the Episode's Plot and Execution
13:40 The Absurdity of the Action Scenes
20:32 Russell and Colter's Bonding
23:41 Rating the Episode
26:00 Discussion on Sibling Dynamics
28:52 Hypothetical Family Business Ventures
39:21 Russell's Backstory and Family Conflict
43:45 Predictions and Conclusion