Absolutely stunning

I am gutted this ended. It’s breathtakingly beautiful and I was lost in the world of Earthia and don’t want to come back out. Can’t wait for the next one.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Loved all the points of view

I loved how this book focused on several of the characters.

Engaging and storyline wasn’t too predictable with some twists in there too.

The protagonists are really coming to their own as well! Looking forward to the next one.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good story, poor editing

Good story somewhat spoiled by repetition but in the end I played a game of counting the repeated words. It helped lol

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Not bad

Overall not bad but I cant believe that there will be more books in the series !. I won't be getting more it has gone on long enough. The story is not that complicated or intricate, its being dragged out too much

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

OK continuation of story

Really enjoyed the middle of this book and Ellorens struggle and reconciliation with Lucas Grey. Disappointed by the end amd outcome for Lucy's. Found the Groundhog Day bit just before the fight very bizarre. Biggest disappointment of the whole book was the star and namesake of the book just being written as a puppet and not really having much fight or story of her own. Also there were just too many threads and stories and it all got a bit confusing. Like the return of Ariel but I've no idea how or why she returned! Maybe we will be lucky in the last book and the same will happen to Lucas. He was a character written with a good amount of depth and dimension and I just didn't buy his demise. There were so many other characters I just didn't care about and after book 3 I wanted to get ny teeth into a good showdown with Elloren & the enemy. Sadly this didn't happen. Oh well, I no doubt will read the last book just to sign off the Series.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Not worth it

On the eve of the battle for Helm's Deep, an eerie purple moon rises...
Gimli glances up at the tall muscled elf stood statuesque beside him on the parapet
"Yo Legolas," he says. "Ever thought about kissing someone?"

If this has been the final book in the series I might have made it through. I can’t cope anymore though. I have no idea who half the characters are/what race they are/ what religion they are or why they all have to be paired into endless romantic relationships while the world is falling apart. I mean endless chapters on who fancies who!!! And I’m bored of all the characters being like ‘wow I was really racist wasn’t I, silly me, let’s all have a love party.’ Everyone's racist or sexist or just totally stupid arrrrggghh. Plus I’ve read spoilers about how the love triangle is resolved and no way am I continuing to the next book for that! Shame as the series had so much potential.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

The same love story like 5 times in parallel???

This time I had to give up. I was gritting my teeth at the "flares through the lines" and incessantly mentioned magic connections in book 3, but I pulled through because I was so invested in the story. This time I can't. Editor, please just stop the repetitions D'': And on top of that, the book so far is basically like 4-5 parallel love stories that are EXACTLY THE SAME ALL OF THEM, but with slight differences and they're stealing way too much attention from the plot for me. I really wanted to follow this to the conclusion, but the repetition was driving me insane.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful