Fantastic

A brilliant book, filled with rich descriptive text, fascinating story and an insight into history told through a remarkable man who I had virtually no prior knowledge of. I highly recommend this book. The writer draws the reader into the story with great skill and from early on in the book I was enthralled.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Fact Meets Fiction In World War II France

Jo Baker has a great talent for putting history on the page in unusual contexts. Her first novel, Longbourn, told the story of Pride And Prejudice from the viewpoint of the servants. This new novel tells the story of writer Samuel Beckett's wartime experiences in WWII France, in a fiction that is clever and deftly written. No prior knowledge of Beckett's work is needed to enjoy it.

The story begins in Paris, just before everything changes when the city falls to the Nazis. During the course of the plot we learn of the author's friendship with James Joyce, his desperation to avoid returning to his native Ireland, his flight from Paris with his lover Suzanne, his times with the French Resistance and his failure to progress the writing career he so badly wanted. After the war he works for an organisation which sets up a hospital in France and he rekindles his relationship with Suzanne. But, love does not prosper and he resumes his writing career.

This is a masterful piece of storytelling. The plot is straightforward, told in a linear style over several different time periods. The characters are well drawn and the story is interesting; there are no literary fireworks and the pace is a little slow at times, but overall it is a good read and very well written.

The narrator did a good job but I would have preferred more light and shade in his tone.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

An intimate story of the Nazi occupation of Paris

I've listened to this twice now and I'll listen again, and again. It's a beautifully written, close, personal, and intimate account of the Nazi occupation of Paris at the start of the second world war. The prose is human - so elegant you don't notice it unless you're looking, and so plain you could easily think it must have been a doddle to write - unless you're really looking. A fictionalised account of Samuel Beckett's own experiences, the story is, at heart, one of ordinary people with decent lives slowly adjusting to starvation, degradation, and the disappearance of friends. If ever we needed a reminder of such creeping imposition of a malignant regime, the disbelief that facilitates it, the imperceptible loss of rights and freedoms, comforts and dignity now is the time. The narration is perfect.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

A Hard Read

Would you try another book written by Jo Baker or narrated by David Rintoul?

David Rintoul is excellent as always in his narration.

Would you recommend A Country Road, a Tree to your friends? Why or why not?

I only listened to 30 minutes of this book,I found it very hard to follow and understand,
I have little doubt it is well written all I can say is it started with two people talking and It took 30 minutes for me to realise it was a man talking to his mother,Instead of just making it clear from the start as to who was who.
No doubt it is a well written book ,but I just found it hard work and gave up after 30 minutes.
I have marked performance high as David Rintoul is my favourite narrator. I dont know if it is a good story as I gave up so early.But some people may like the style in which the book is written.

What three words best describe David Rintoul’s voice?

very,very good

Could you see A Country Road, a Tree being made into a movie or a TV series? Who would the stars be?

I cannot say.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Boring Book

extremely wordy, story jumps around all the time. Difficult to get a grip of. utterly boring. Only persevered as it was for a book club. Not worth the money.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!